AWS CloudFormation vs Google Cloud Deployment Manager - A Comparison
Cloud Orchestration tools have become a crucial part of managing complex cloud infrastructure. AWS CloudFormation and Google Cloud Deployment Manager are two leading cloud orchestration tools that compete with each other in the market. In this article, we'll compare AWS CloudFormation and Google Cloud Deployment Manager and provide an unbiased comparison of the two tools.
Overview
AWS CloudFormation and Google Cloud Deployment Manager are infrastructure as a code (IaC) tools that allow users to define and manage cloud infrastructure on their respective cloud platforms. Both tools are essential for automating infrastructure deployment, and they use YAML or JSON templates to define the infrastructure. Both tools also provide features like version control, rollbacks, and scaling of resources.
Comparison
Let's compare AWS CloudFormation and Google Cloud Deployment Manager based on different parameters.
Language Support
AWS CloudFormation supports JSON and YAML to define infrastructure, while Google Cloud Deployment Manager supports only YAML. YAML is more human-readable, so even if it's slightly less powerful than JSON, it's still preferable.
Resource Support
AWS CloudFormation supports a broader range of resources than Google Cloud Deployment Manager, including resources like EMR, AWS Lambda, and EFS. In contrast, Google Cloud Deployment Manager supports resources like GKE, Kubernetes clusters, and App Engine. AWS CloudFormation's wider range of resources makes it more flexible for complex infrastructure management.
Availability
AWS CloudFormation has a higher global presence than Google Cloud Deployment Manager, with 25 available regions compared to Google Cloud's 24.
Security
AWS CloudFormation provides more granular security control over IAM policies, letting users assign policies to specific resources. Google Cloud Deployment Manager, on the other hand, offers coarse-grained security control.
Pricing
Both AWS CloudFormation and Google Cloud Deployment Manager are free to use. However, charges apply for the resources provisioned using the tools. AWS CloudFormation charges $0.0002 per resource provisioned, while Google Cloud Deployment Manager charges $0.10 per resource provisioned.
Conclusion
AWS CloudFormation and Google Cloud Deployment Manager are both excellent orchestration tools, and the choice between the two depends on your organization's requirements. If you're looking for a wider range of resources and a more extensive global presence, AWS CloudFormation is the better choice. But if you're looking for better language support and a lower cost of use, Google Cloud Deployment Manager is the better choice for you.